One of my life goals is to own all of the Urban Decay 24/7 pencils. Of course, I should probably worry about graduating school and getting a job before I drop $400 for 23 eyeliners.
But for those of you who love the smooth, glide-on texture and staying power of these pencils, fear not! There are some great drugstore alternatives out there for a fraction of the cost. I’m sure there are many more than the two I’m reviewing in this post, and if you know of a good one, please leave it in the comments.
from left to right: (Top row: Carmindy for Sally Hansen Forever Stay Eye Pencils in Deep Jade, Blue Indigo, Pure Plum; Bottom: Prestige Waterproof Eye Pencils in Star, Granite).
These pencils go on the same as Urban Decay’s, with no tugging whatsoever. They have good staying power (I don’t wear liner on my waterline, ever, so I don’t know how well they stay on there), and although the colors don’t get as cool as the 24/7 pencils, they still have a pretty decent selection.
As for which of the two brands I prefer, Prestige has a slight edge over Sally Hansen. Why?
Sally Hansen’s pencils go from $8-$9, depending on where you get them. Prestige prices them around $5 each.
Sally Hansen’s colors are nice, but Prestige has a wider selection, and I prefer the shimmery finish (Sally Hansen’s pencils are not shimmery at all, which could be a good or bad thing depending on your preferences).
Both are very creamy, but Prestige’s pencils apply slightly better than Sally Hansen’s do. It’s not really that much of a difference, but I think the finish of Prestige’s pencils are dead-on for Urban Decay.
Overall, either of these are great buys for someone who wants to get the most for their money. Do I still dream of owning those UD pencils? Yeah, I do. But since I’d rather not live on the street with those 23 *so very gorgeous* eyeliners as my only friends, I think I’ll go for these instead.